A Madden-Ing Disappointment

NOTE: This musing also appears today on our sister site THE DOUBLE OVERTIME. Please visit it regularly for coverage of sports of all sorts plus regular essays on business and technology.

I do tend to pivot toward negativity at times, and I’ll allow that lately that’s been more frequently than not my default.  But honestly, I was REALLY looking forward to MADDEN, the biopic of the legendary coach, sportscaster and video game icon John which Prime Video opportunistically dropped last night.  With a Thursday Night game as marginal as tonight’s “showdown” between two teams–the Houston Texans and Indianapolis Colts–who have a combined six wins as Week Eleven begins–they certainly can use a boost to this week’s numbers.

Looking at the credits, there was ample reason for at least me to be excited.  There are some quite impressive names attached to this whose works I generally like.  Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, John Mulaney and Shane Gillis in leading roles.  David O. Russell as director.  And a subject I’m EXTREMELY familiar with.  I’m seasoned and connected enough to both know and respect why Madden was such a success in all three of his careers.  His detailed knowledge, passion and authenticity combined with an everyman personality made him extraordinarily relatable to football fans of multiple generations and helped sell a lot of beer and foot powder.  I know plenty of people who worked with him and all pretty much had the same reaction.  Quirky, to be sure, and at times moody, but a brain that was always moving at warp speed when football was involved.

I really wish Russell had even attempted to tape into that BEAUTIFUL MIND-like vibe in the manner which he did with a fan in SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK so brilliantly.  I really wish the cast’s collective abilities to fully transform themselves into the roles and personalities they portray were allowed to do so without lapsing back and forth between satirical cartoon and legitimate portrayal.  I really wish a timeline which folks of my vintage can rattle off with pinpoint accuracy was adhered to more often that the lame “creative direction” hall pass that too many producers and directors pull out to justify their version of what the story they want to tell.

It seemed to me that Russell believed he was primarily aiming to tell the origin story of an iconic brand such that MADDEN football is.  This morning TIME’s Sean Gregory postulated just that himself:

The creation of the Madden video game franchise, one of the best-selling sports titles in history, is covered in the third act…the scenes concerning the video game, with comedian John Mulaney portraying…founder of video-game publisher Electronic Arts (EA) Trip…Hawkins, stand out, as they shed light on one of the more underexplored, though arguably most important, aspects of his legacy. 

In 1984,…Hawkins, boarded an Amtrak train in Denver for a meeting that would one day prove monumental. He walked into the dining car to pitch ..Madden, the CBS football commentator and omnipresent commercial spokesman who famously feared flying, on lending his name to a football video game Hawkins wanted to create.  Hawkins explained to Madden that there was just one hitch. Since the 8-bit home consoles of that era did not have the technological capability to replicate an actual 11-vs.-11 NFL game, Hawkins proposed that Madden support a 7-vs.-7 version of football. Madden, who won a Super Bowl as coach of the Oakland Raiders in 1977 and grew even more famous explaining the intricacies of trench warfare at the line of scrimmage to millions of viewers—through exhortations like “BOOM!” and “BAM!”—responded that a watered-down version of football, without a bunch of broad-shouldered linemen slamming into one another, was unacceptable. 

It’s those scenes, where Cage and Mulaney’s respective abilities to be both understated and immersed at once are showcased, and where Russell literally returns to the storyline of a coveted playbook which to me showed what the potential of MADDEN was.  The family scenes, especially where Hahn’s presence as the complicated compliment of a wife that is Virginia Madden is on display, show similarly encouraging signs of depth and relatability, showcasing a more vulnerable and sensitive side of a football coach whose primary marriage is to his sport.

At the same time, those scenes also expose the confirmed reality that neither the real Virginia nor Trip were consulted by Russell and his team.  What unfolds becomes almost schizophrenically both biopic and SNL sketch, never really deciding which direction to ultimately take.  Clearly exaggerated cameos that feature names like Bob Costas, Pat Summerall and Howard Cosell are portrayed by actors who don’t hold a candle to how they’ve been portrayed in far simpler works.

But I’ll save my greatest disdain for how Bale attempted to portray mercurial Raiders owner Al Davis and Russell’s choice to elevate him to practically a co-starring role.  Fact is, Davis and Madden weren’t quite as joined at the hip as the movie’s overarching first and second acts depicted–a triviality not lost on the likes of SCREEN RANT’s Josh Bate:

They are extremely close, yet, at the same time, also butt heads often, and their disagreements are the cause of many drama-filled moments in the new film.

Madden shows many of these clashes between the two, where Nicolas Cage’s character and Al Davis (played by Christian Bale) are in disagreement with one another. However, it seems the truth is that the two didn’t clash as much as the film suggests, and that many of these moments were added for the sake of dramatization…As producer Todd Black stated in a panel at the Virginia Film Festival (via IndieWire), the movie’s intention was never to provide a story only drawn from real life, as “we were trying to make it an entertaining story without making it a documentary. So some stuff was inspired by, some stuff was true, and a lot of stuff we made up, not wildly, but just for entertainment value.”

Anyone who watched FOX’s seminal ALL MADDEN documentary that proved to be a welcome Christmas Day gift five years ago–and there were quite a number such folks given the fact that Madden’s passing three days later resulted in multiple linear airs and elevated holiday online viewing–know a lot more about the real Madden, and especially what those with NFL affiliations thought of him.  What panned out to be eulogies were both poignant and hilarious.  And with Madden providing one last chance to demonstrate his unparalleled ability for commentary as he screened them with FOX SPORTS’ Tom Rinaldi and Joel Santos, ALL MADDEN provided far more authenticity and insight into his career–and indeed his life–than anything we saw from Russell’s efforts.

I devoured that special in the same voracious way I did when I was offered turducken, which Madden’s love for took that otherwise obscure mashup of three different poultries to its own iconic status where drumsticks for outstanding Thanksgiving Day performers became coveted, albeit edible, trophies.  I was really hoping that with something so significant and recent Russell and Black would have least chosen to follow it for framing and accuracy.  Especially when the subject was so darn authentic in how he presented himself in his lifetime.  The decision to instead produce “entertainment value” like MADDEN aspires to yet miserably fails to be, left me with much the same feeling that turducken tends to these days after three stomach surgeries.   Wishing I still had the capacity to throw up.

Until next time…

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x